Foliar chemical composition and respiration rates of sugar maple (Acer saccharum) and American beech (Fagus grandifolia) trees across a gradient of soil acidification

Acidic deposition has been well studied for its impacts on forest soils and plants and is thought to detrimentally affect sugar maple (Acer saccharum) in northeastern North America. The physiological mechanism driving reduced tree growth on acid impaired sites is not well understood, but has been suggested to involve increased autotrophic respiration rates. We measured foliar respiration and leaf elemental composition on two species with contrasting acid tolerances (sugar maple and American beech, Fagus grandifolia) across a naturally occurring soil base saturation (BS) gradient in the Adirondack Mountains of New York. Foliar chemistry varied strongly as anticipated across the BS gradient, with decreases in base cations and increases in phytotoxic metals (e.g., Mn) on sites with highly acidified soils. However, foliar respiration rates were not correlated with most measures of acidity (e.g., BS, foliar concentrations of Ca, Mg, Al content). Respiration rates did correlate with other leaf traits (N content, leaf mass per unit area) reflective of leaf morphological variation in response to variable light availability. After accounting for multivariate trait covariation, mass-based respiration rates were associated with foliar Mn content, suggesting a positive relationship between the concentration of this phytotoxic metal and foliar respiration rates. Soluble foliar Ca, Mg, and Mn were closely correlated with total foliar concentrations of these elements. Overall these results demonstrate that soil acidification and loss of base cations is largely unrelated to foliar respiration rates, although the accumulation of foliar Mn on acidified soils may contribute to the metabolic burden of both sugar maple and American beech trees.

Automated summary

Acidic deposition has been found to negatively impact sugar maple in northeastern North America, but the physiological mechanisms are not well understood. In this study, foliar respiration rates were measured on sugar maple and American beech across a soil base saturation gradient. Results showed that foliar respiration rates were not correlated with acidity measures, but were associated with leaf traits related to light availability and foliar Mn content. These findings suggest that soil acidification is unrelated to foliar respiration rates, but the accumulation of foliar Mn on acidified soils may contribute to metabolic burden in trees.