Bias in expert product reviews

Many expert reviews of products such as cars, books, movies and restaurants are non -blind. Whether such reviews can be taken at face value is questionable, but hard evidence on the presence of reviewer bias is rare. This holds particularly true for conflicts of interest that are thought to be common in non-blind product reviews but are not readily observ-able: ad hoc relationships between reviewers and producers. We present a textbook case of a long-running expert product review in the food service industry for which we know the reviewer's conflict of interest: being affiliated to one particular producer. As is typical, only insiders were aware of the possible source of bias in the review. The review resembles other non-blind tests of product quality. We find evidence of a sizable bias in the review-ers' ratings. Our findings suggest that reviewers' ad hoc relationships with producers, often dismissed as 'coming with the job', can be very harmful. (c) 2022 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY license ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ )

Automated summary

Many expert reviews of products are non-blind and may be biased due to reviewers' ad hoc relationships with producers. This study provides evidence of a sizable bias in a long-running expert product review in the food service industry.