Genetic variation for effects of drought stress on yield formation traits among commercial soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] cultivars adapted to Ontario, Canada

Drought stress significantly limits soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] yields in Ontario, Canada. Many studies of genetic variation for drought tolerance compare commercial lines with exotic, unadapted germplasm. We hypothesized that even current commercial cultivars adapted to Ontario would differ significantly for traits related to drought tolerance. In a greenhouse experiment, we grew fifteen soybean cultivars in field soil amended with sand in 1-m rooting columns, which allowed for simulation of field-like soil water profiles and rooting depths. Two watering treatments were imposed from the first flower until maturity by daily restoration of soil water to either 100% (control), or 50% (drought stress) of the maximum soil water holding capacity. Throughout the experiment, we measured volumetric soil water content at different depths in the soil profile, but found no evidence at any developmental stage that the cultivars differed for their ability to extract soil water from different depths. Drought stress reduced seed yield by 51% on average. Similar to the effects of drought in the field, pod number was the yield component most affected, with effects on seeds per pod and single-seed weight being comparatively minor. There were significant cultivar x treatment interactions for seed yield, pod number, shoot dry matter, and water use. We identified two drought-sensitive (Saska and OAC Drayton) and three drought-tolerant (OAC Lakeview, OAC Champion, and PRO 2715R) cultivars based on their ratios of seed yield under drought stress to seed yield under control conditions (seed yield ratio, SYR). Regression and principal component analyses revealed that drought-tolerant (high-SYR) cultivars were consistently those that maintained relatively high values for water use, biomass accumulation and pod number under drought stress; high water use efficiency under drought stress was also associated with a high SYR. One of the cultivars, OAC Lakeview, displayed a distinct mode of drought tolerance, maintaining a very high fraction of its control pod number under drought stress. This study helps define the physiological basis of soybean cultivar differences in drought tolerance, and provides direction for soybean breeders to select traits that could improve yield under drought stress.

Automated summary

Drought stress significantly limits soybean yields in Ontario, Canada. This study found that current commercial cultivars adapted to Ontario differ significantly in traits related to drought tolerance. Drought stress reduced seed yield by 51% on average, with pod number being the most affected yield component. Two drought-sensitive and three drought-tolerant cultivars were identified based on their seed yield ratio under drought stress to control conditions. Drought-tolerant cultivars maintained high values for water use, biomass accumulation, and pod number under drought stress.