Comment on the calculation of equilibrium constant and thermodynamic parameters by the distribution coefficient in Environmental Research 203 (2022) 111814

This comment discussed the calculation of equilibrium constant and thermodynamic parameters in the paper of Kayalvizhi et al. (2022). This paper is of high academic value, however, there are some calculation and quotation errrors. The equilibrium constant K evolved from the distribution coefficient has a dimension of L/g, which is not the standard equilibrium constant, therefore, it cannot be used to calculate the thermodynamic parameters. This comment firstly analyzed the calculation errors made by Kayalvizhi et al. (2022), then established the relationship between distribution coefficient and standard equilibirum constant, and recalculated the thermodynamic parameters by using the correct distribution coefficient equation. As a research paper, authors not only provide the originality and novelty, but also give its correct results. This comment can bring to the attention of readers, authors, editors and reviewers about the thermodynamic calculation. At the same time, it is helpful to avoid the misuse and propagation of the incorrect equation in the area of adsorption thermodynamics.

Automated summary

This comment reviewed the paper by Kayalvizhi et al. (2022) and pointed out the calculation and quotation errors, providing the correct approach. The results of this comment are valuable for researchers, editors, reviewers, and readers in the field.