Spatial evolution of cooperation with variable payoffs

In the evolution of cooperation, the individuals' payoffs are commonly random in real situations, e.g., the social networks and the economic regions, leading to unpredictable factors. Therefore, there are chances for each individual to obtain the exceeding payoff and risks to get the low payoff. In this paper, we consider that each individual's payoff follows a specific probability distribution with a fixed expectation, where the normal distribution and the exponential distribution are employed in our model. In the simulations, we perform the models on the weak prisoner's dilemmas (WPDs) and the snowdrift games (SDGs), and four types of networks, including the hexagon lattice, the square lattice, the small-world network, and the triangular lattice are considered. For the individuals' normally distributed payoff, we find that the higher standard deviation usually inhibits the cooperation for the WPDs but promotes the cooperation for the SDGs. Besides, with a higher standard deviation, the cooperation clusters are usually split for the WPDs but constructed for the SDGs. For the individuals' exponentially distributed payoff, we find that the small-world network provides the best condition for the emergence of cooperators in WPDs and SDGs. However, when playing SDGs, the small-world network allows the smallest space for the pure cooperative state while the hexagon lattice allows the largest.

Automated summary

In the evolution of cooperation, the randomness of individuals' payoffs in real situations introduces unpredictable factors. This study investigates the effects of payoff distribution and network structure on cooperation using simulations. The results show that for normally distributed payoffs, a higher standard deviation inhibits cooperation in one scenario but promotes it in another. For exponentially distributed payoffs, the small-world network provides the best conditions for cooperation emergence.