What has happened and what has not happened due to the coronavirus disease pandemic: a systemic perspective on policy change

The societal and policy transformations associated with the coronavirus disease pandemic are currently subject of intense academic debate. In this paper, we contribute to this debate by adopting a systemic perspective on policy change, shedding light on the hidden and indirect crisis effects. Based on a comprehensive analysis of policy agenda developments in Germany, we find that the pandemic led to profound shifts in political attention across policy areas. We demonstrate that these agenda gains and losses per policy area vary by the extent to which the respective areas can be presented as relevant in managing the coronavirus disease crisis and its repercussions. Moreover, relying on the analysis of past four economic crises, we also find that there is limited potential for catching up dynamics after the crisis is over. Policy areas that lost agenda share during crisis are unlikely to make up for these losses by strong attention gains once the crisis is over. Crises have hence substantial, long-term and so far, neglected effects on policymaking in modern democracies.

Automated summary

This paper contributes to the ongoing academic debate on the societal and policy transformations associated with the coronavirus disease pandemic by adopting a systemic perspective on policy change. The study sheds light on the hidden and indirect crisis effects and finds that the pandemic has led to profound shifts in political attention across policy areas in Germany. The research also suggests that there is limited potential for catching up dynamics after the crisis is over, which has long-term and neglected effects on policymaking in modern democracies.