4.7 Review

The interactions of site-specific factors on riparian buffer effectiveness across multiple pollutants: A review

期刊

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT
卷 798, 期 -, 页码 -

出版社

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.149238

关键词

Riparian buffer zone; Site; Soil; Vegetation; Pollution retention; Effectiveness; Width

资金

  1. Irish EPA [2017-W-LS-16]
  2. Environmental Protection Agency Ireland (EPA) [2017-W-LS-16] Funding Source: Environmental Protection Agency Ireland (EPA)

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Decades of research on riparian buffer zones (RBZ) have shown the need to look across individual site data for collective evidence on pollution mitigation and river water quality. The research findings indicate that factors related to sediment, phosphorus, nitrogen, coliforms and pesticides retention in RBZ are affected by factors such as buffer width, clay particle size, and slope, with inconsistency in the reporting of other pollutant-specific factors. The study suggests revisiting vegetation management studies, extending study durations, and considering belowground soil biogeochemical and transport processes to better understand site-specific buffer functioning and reduce pollution swapping.
Following decades of riparian buffer zone (RBZ) studies there remains a need to look across individual site data for collective evidence on the site-specific pollution mitigation and river water quality. We explored primary study evidence on runoff, sediment, P, N, coliforms and pesticides using complimentary styles of metadata interpretation. A quantitative assessment of pollution retention (75 studies, 474 data rows) derived relationships for retention versus width, including significant covariates of clay particle size and buffer slope for sediment, total and dissolved P. Total N and coliforms related to texture and slope but were independent of width. Other factors across pollutants were inconsistently reported. With limitations on quantitative studies a second approach examined factor significance (formal testing versus inferred; 93 studies) across source pressure, transport/physical, vegetation and soil biogeochemical factors on pollution effectiveness. The RBZ evidence showed considerable disagreement and bias in shorter term study implications on longer-term processes. Screening for stronger evidence by study number and agreement left fifteen factors informing on at least one pollutant, whereas only rainfall intensity, preferential deposition, tree planting, soil infiltration remained addressing three or more pollutants. Key messages were that: data complexities, from short-term trapping in upper buffer edges and so-called 'negative effectiveness' associated with internal recycling and/or errors in constraining mass inputs for dissolved pollutant and subsurface transport require careful interpretation; RBZ intervention and study durations were limited compared to effect times (particularly vegetation management and changing soil conditions); factors affect pollutants with particulate and dissolved phases differently and must be understood to limit RBZ pollution swapping. Buffer functioning is highly site-specific. To understand this better attention should be given to revisiting studies of vegetation management to extend timeframes, wider study of belowground (soil biogeochemical and transport) processes and studies should document site contexts across source pressures, riparian hydrological, soil and vegetation factors. (c) 2021 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

暂无数据
暂无数据