Prognostic biomarkers for predicting papillary thyroid carcinoma patients at high risk using nine genes of apoptotic pathway

Aberrant expressions of apoptotic genes have been associated with papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) in the past, however, their prognostic role and utility as biomarkers remains poorly understood. In this study, we analysed 505 PTC patients by employing Cox-PH regression techniques, prognostic index models and machine learning methods to elucidate the relationship between overall survival (OS) of PTC patients and 165 apoptosis related genes. It was observed that nine genes (ANXA1, TGFBR3, CLU, PSEN1, TNFRSF12A, GPX4, TIMP3, LEF1, BNIP3L) showed significant association with OS of PTC patients. Five out of nine genes were found to be positively correlated with OS of the patients, while the remaining four genes were negatively correlated. These genes were used for developing risk prediction models, which can be utilized to classify patients with a higher risk of death from the patients which have a good prognosis. Our voting-based model achieved highest performance (HR = 41.59, p = 3.36x10(-4), C = 0.84, logrank-p = 3.8x10(-8)). The performance of voting-based model improved significantly when we used the age of patients with prognostic biomarker genes and achieved HR = 57.04 with p = 10(-4) (C = 0.88, logrank-p = 1.44x10(-9)). We also developed classification models that can classify high risk patients (survival <= 6 years) and low risk patients (survival > 6 years). Our best model achieved AUROC of 0.92. Further, the expression pattern of the prognostic genes was verified at mRNA level, which showed their differential expression between normal and PTC samples. Also, the immunostaining results from HPA validated these findings. Since these genes can also be used as potential therapeutic targets in PTC, we also identified potential drug molecules which could modulate their expression profile. The study briefly revealed the key prognostic biomarker genes in the apoptotic pathway whose altered expression is associated with PTC progression and aggressiveness. In addition to this, risk assessment models proposed here can help in efficient management of PTC patients.

Automated summary

This study identified 9 apoptotic genes associated with overall survival in 505 PTC patients, with 5 genes showing a positive correlation and 4 genes showing a negative correlation. Risk prediction models and classification models were developed based on these genes, aiding in efficient management of PTC patients. The study also verified the expression pattern of these prognostic genes and identified potential drug molecules to modulate their expression profiles for potential therapeutic targets in PTC.