Dual-energy CT hybridation and kernel processing effects on the estimation of bone mineral mass and density: a calcination study on ex vivo human femur

Introduction Recent technological advances with dual-energy quantitative computed tomography (DEQCT) allow to combine two images of different level of energy to obtain simulated mono-energetic images at 60 keV ((SIM)60KeV-QCT) with improved image contrast in clinical practice. This study includes three topics: (1) compare bone mineral content (BMC), areal and volumetric bone mineral density (aBMD, vBMD) obtained with (SIM)60KeV-QCT, single-energy QCT (SEQCT), and dual X-ray absorptiometry (DXA); (2) compare ash density and weight with respective vBMD and BMC assessed on sim 60KeV-QCT, SEQCT, and DXA; and (3) compare the influence of reconstruction kernels on the accuracy of vBMD and BMC using ash density and ash weight as the reference values. Methods DXA, SEQCT, and DEQCT acquisitions were performed ex vivo on 42 human femurs. Standard kernel (SK) and bone kernel (BK) were applied to each stack of images. Ten diaphyses and 10 femoral necks were cut, scanned, and reconstructed using the techniques described above. Finally, the bone specimens were calcined to obtain the ash weight. Results QCT analysis (SEQCT, (SIM)60KeV-QCT) underestimated BMC value compared to DXA. For femoral necks, all QCT analyses provided an unbiased estimate of ash weight but underestimated ash density regardless of the kernel used. For femoral diaphysis, SEQCT BK, (SIM)60KeV-QCT BK, and SK underestimated ash weight but not ash density. Conclusion BMC and vBMD quantifications with the sim 60KeV-QCT gave similar results as the SEQCT. Further studies are needed to optimize the use of (SIM)60KeV-QCT in clinical situations. SK should be used given the effect of kernels on QCT assessment.

Automated summary

The study compared the differences in bone mineral content and bone density measurements between (SIM)60KeV-QCT, SEQCT, and DXA, and found that the use of different reconstruction kernels had a certain impact on the results.