Experimental assessment of the effect of net wing spread on relative catch efficiency of four flatfishes by a four seam bottom trawl

The northeast US fishing industry and other stakeholders have considerable interest in the quality of bottom trawl survey results because of their importance in the setting of quotas, especially those directly derived from bottom trawl indices measured in catch per area swept by the survey net. Net spread (also referred to as wing spread) impacts catches and thus indices and, for the federal northeast bottom trawl survey, it is correlated with the depth at which a tow is performed. As part of an ongoing partnership between the Northeast Fisheries Science Center, the New England and Mid-Atlantic Fisheries Management Councils, members of the fishing industry, and academics in the region, an experiment to evaluate the impact of wing spread on the catchability of a number of species was conducted in the Fall of 2019 on the F/V Karen Elizabeth. The experiment targeted four species of flatfishes using a twin trawl rigging to collect simultaneous observations of catch and wing spread relative to a controlled optimal net spread. We analyzed these data to estimate the effect of net spread on relative catch efficiency and to evaluate the hypothesis that relative catch efficiency decreases as net spread departs from the optimal configuration. We found that, while the total catch was impacted by net wing spread (catches increased with increasing swept-area), there was no evidence of a wing spread effect on relative catch efficiency for any of the flatfish species. These results suggest that bottom trawl surveys should account for swept-area of individual tows, but that it is not necessary to incorporate species- or length-specific efficiency conversions based on the width of the net.

Automated summary

The fishing industry in the northeast US is highly interested in the quality of bottom trawl survey results, as they are crucial for setting quotas. An experiment evaluating the impact of net spread on the catchability of flatfish species found that while total catch was affected by net wing spread, there was no evidence of a wing spread effect on relative catch efficiency for any of the species.