Nonstarter Bacterial Communities in Aged Cheddar Cheese: Patterns on Two Timescales

The aim of this study was to investigate the temporal stability of microbial contamination during cheddar cheese production by examining patterns of nonstarter bacteria in 60-day aged cheddar collected from the start and end of 30 consecutive production days. Further, we explored the source of these temporal microbial variations by comparing microbial communities in the aged cheese to those on food contact surfaces from a piece of cheesemaking equipment previously identified as a major source of nonstarter bacteria in the same processing environment. 16S rRNA metabarcoding and culture-based sequencing methods identified two Streptococcus sequence variants significantly associated with the end of the production day in both the aged cheese and the cheese processing environment. Closer inspection of these sequence variants in the aged cheese over the 40-day sampling period revealed sinusoidal-like fluctuations in their relative ratios, which appeared to coincide with the Lactococcus starter rotation schedule. These results demonstrate that the microbial composition of finished cheese can vary according to the timing of processing within a production day. Further, our results demonstrate that time-of-day microbial differences in cheese can result from bacterial growth on food contact surfaces and that the composition of these microbial differences is subject to change day-to-day and may be linked to routine changes in the Lactococcus starter culture. IMPORTANCE Long production schedules used in modern cheese manufacturing can create circumstances that support the growth of microorganisms in the cheese processing environment. This work demonstrates that this growth can lead to significant changes in the microbial quality of aged cheese produced later in the production day. Further, we demonstrate that the dominant bacteria associated with these microbial changes throughout production are subject to change between days and might be influenced by specific cheese manufacturing practices. These findings improve understanding of microbial contamination patterns in modern food manufacturing facilities, thereby improving our ability to develop strategies to minimize quality losses due to microbial spoilage.

Automated summary

This study investigated the temporal stability of microbial contamination during cheddar cheese production and found that the timing of processing within a production day can affect the microbial composition of the finished cheese. Furthermore, bacterial growth on food contact surfaces and routine changes in the starter culture may contribute to microbial differences in cheese.