Validated programmed cell death ligand 1 immunohistochemistry assays (E1L3N and SP142) reveal similar immune cell staining patterns in melanoma when using the same sensitive detection system

Aims: Tumour cell and/or immune cell programmed cell death ligand 1 (PD-L1) expression is considered as a potential biomarker for anti-PD1 and anti-PD-L1 immunotherapy. Currently, different PD-L1 assays are used. This study aims to compare the staining patterns of two PD-L1 antibody clones in melanoma metastases and correlate them with PD-L1 mRNA expression. Methods and results: The immunohistochemistry assays were optimized and validated independently on a Ventana Benchmark Ultra (Ventana Medical Systems Inc., Tucson, AZ, USA) (E1L3N) and XT (SP142), using the same detection system. In total, 46 melanoma metastases were stained with both validated immunohistochemistry assays. Stained slides were digitized for qualitative and semi-quantitative evaluation; done by pathologist and semi-automated software analysis. A subset of 21 melanoma metastases was selected for quantification of the PDL1 mRNA expression. Accuracy and precision criteria were met for both assays. PD-L1 protein and mRNA expression showed remarkably good Spearman's coefficients of 0.90 (E1L3N) and 0.87 (SP142). Despite the remarkable correlation between both PD-L1 assays in expression patterns and quantification values (q > 0.90), E1L3N showed significantly more tumour cell staining than SP142. Conclusions: E1L3N and SP142 IHC assays were optimized and validated successfully and independently for sensitive and accurate PD-L1 detection. Concordance was best for immune cell scoring, while E1L3N tended to detect more tumour cells. Determination of the clinically relevant cut-off values for immune cell versus tumour cell detection requires further research.