The Role of Cerebral Metabolism in Improving Time Pressured Decisions

Speed-accuracy tradeoff (SAT) theory dictates that decisions can be made more quickly by sacrificing accuracy. Here we investigate whether the human brain can operate in a brief metabolic overdrive to overcome SAT and successfully make decisions requiring both high levels of speed and accuracy. In the context of BOLD fMRI we expect a brief metabolic overdrive to involve an increase in cerebral oxygen metabolism prior to increased cerebral blood flow-a phenomenon known as the initial dip which results from a sudden drop in oxyhemoglobin in perfusing blood. Human subjects performed a motion discrimination task consisting of different difficulties while emphasizing either accuracy (i.e., without time pressure) or both speed and accuracy (i.e., with time pressure). Using simultaneous multi-slice fMRI, for very fast (333 ms) measurement of whole brain BOLD activity, revealed two modes of physiological overdrive responses when subjects emphasized both speed and accuracy. The majority of subjects exhibited the hypothesized enhancement of initial dip amplitude in posterior visual cortex (PVC) with the size of the enhancement significantly correlated with improvement in behavioral performance. For these subjects, the traditionally analyzed post-stimulus overshoot was not affected by task emphasis. These results demonstrate the complexity and variability of the BOLD hemodynamic response. The discovered relationships between BOLD response and behavior were only observed when subjects emphasized both speed and accuracy in more difficult trials suggesting that the brain can perform in a state of metabolic overdrive with enhanced neural processing of sensory information specifically in challenging situations.

Automated summary

The study investigated whether the human brain can operate in a brief metabolic overdrive to successfully make decisions requiring high levels of speed and accuracy. Results revealed two modes of physiological overdrive responses in subjects emphasizing both speed and accuracy, with most showing enhancement of initial dip amplitude in the posterior visual cortex correlated with behavioral improvement. The relationship between BOLD response and behavior was observed specifically in challenging situations when subjects emphasized both speed and accuracy.