Thyroid nodules with indeterminate cytology: association between nodule size, histopathological characteristics and clinical outcome in differentiated thyroid carcinomas - a multicenter retrospective cohort study on 761 patients

A great number of surgical diagnostic procedures are performed every year for thyroid nodules that are included in undetermined cytological classes that reveal to be malignant thyroid carcinomas in one-third of cases. In the most recent guidelines, lobectomy is the most recommended surgical approach for this classes of nodules, but total thyroidectomy is the recommended treatment for undetermined nodules larger than 4 cm. The main study aim is to support or question the dimensional criteria as an independent clinical decision element for undetermined thyroid nodules management. We examined data regarding 761 patients undergoing thyroid surgery for undetermined thyroid nodules at two high-volume endocrine surgery units in Italy. Patients were divided into three groups based on the preoperative size of the nodules (N < 1, 1 < N < 4, N > 4 cm). Among the patients belonging to the different groups, we analyzed: differences in malignancy rate, histological characteristics of invasiveness and neoplastic aggressiveness, rates of recurrence and response to therapy. Nodule size (evaluated as a categorical variable and as a continuous variable) did not show any statistically significant correlation with the rate of malignancy, histopathological characteristics of tumor aggressiveness and the patient's clinical outcome. Most of the tumors found were included in the low risk class (79.2%) and only one was classified as high risk. Follow up of cancer cases showed excellent results in terms of survival, response to therapy and disease recurrence. Malignant thyroid tumors of any size resulting from a nodule identified as cytologically indeterminate are usually characterized by a low risk follicular pattern, well-differentiated and with an excellent outcome. As a result, preferring an extended surgical attitude for undetermined nodules based on tumor size, in absence of other risk factors, can lead to overtreatment in a significant percentage of cases.

Automated summary

A study of 761 patients undergoing thyroid surgery for undetermined nodules revealed that nodule size did not correlate significantly with malignancy rate, histological characteristics, or patient outcomes. Most tumors identified were low-risk follicular pattern with good treatment response and survival outcomes. Overtreatment may result from selecting surgical approaches based solely on nodule size in the absence of other risk factors.