Effects of species diversity on fine root productivity in diverse ecosystems: a global meta-analysis

AimPositive relationships between plant species diversity and above-ground productivity have been observed across a wide range of terrestrial ecosystems. Despite a critical contribution of below-ground productivity to overall terrestrial productivity, no consensus exists about the nature of the relationship between species diversity and below-ground productivity. LocationGlobal. MethodsWe collected data from published studies conducted in natural and planted forests and experimental grassland, crop and pot systems that were purposely implemented to isolate the effects of plant species diversity from other factors, such as soil conditions and topographic features. We conducted meta-analyses of 170 observations for root biomass and 23 observations for root production, derived from 48 published studies, using weighted linear modelling with bootstrap procedures to reconcile the effects of diversity on fine root productivity. ResultsWe found that species mixtures had, on average 28.4% higher fine root biomass and 44.8% higher annual production than monocultures. Higher fine root biomass in species mixtures than in monocultures was consistent across natural forests, planted grasslands, croplands and pot systems, except for young planted forests. Transgressive overyielding was only evident for planted grasslands. The log response ratio of fine root biomass in species mixtures to that in respective monocultures increased with species richness across all ecosystem types, and also increased with experiment age in grasslands. Main conclusionsOur meta-analysis reveals positive effects of species diversity on below-ground productivity. Despite profound differences in environments among terrestrial ecosystems, our analysis demonstrated that below-ground productivity responds similarly to variations in species richness. Furthermore, our study also reveals shifts in the effects of diversity over time in both forests and grasslands. Future efforts are needed to further understand below-ground productivity-diversity relationships.