Sensitivity of dissimilar aluminum to steel resistance spot welds to weld gun deflection

This paper describes an experimental study in which a traditional resistance spot weld process with Multi-Ring Domed (MRD) welding electrodes was used to join AA5754-O to low carbon steel sheets in a coach peel configuration. A linear relationship was identified for the resistance spot weld C-gun stationary arm deflection with force applied by the movable gun arm. Due to the relative rotation of the electrodes during deflection, the point of electrode/coupon surface contact moved away from the original centerline to a point inboard towards the C-gun arm. This led to asymmetric features in aluminum/steel resistance spot weld morphology, intermetallic compound (IMC) characteristics, weld defect distribution, and aluminum hardness. The aluminum weld nugget solidified closer to the weld gun with respect to the centerline of the MRD electrode imprint and exhibited a softer thermo-mechanically affected zone (TMAZ) and expulsion which produced a thinner IMC layer and fewer oxide film defects. This in turn resulted in strong button pull-out strength and the welds were able to absorb 36% more energy under an applied directional load in comparison to aluminum weld nuggets that solidified further away from the weld gun with respect to the electrode imprint centerline. The mechanism responsible for these weld asymmetries was further revealed through analysis of the variation in contact condition between electrodes and workpieces due to weld gun deflection.

Automated summary

This study utilized a traditional resistance spot weld process with Multi-Ring Domed welding electrodes to join AA5754-O to low carbon steel sheets in a coach peel configuration. The research revealed that asymmetric features resulting from relative rotation of the electrodes during deflection affected the resistance spot weld morphology, IMC characteristics, weld defect distribution, and hardness. The mechanism behind these weld asymmetries was further revealed through analysis of the variation in contact condition between electrodes and workpieces due to weld gun deflection.