Climate and the latitudinal limits of subtropical reef development

Climate plays a central role in coral-reef development, especially in marginal environments. The high-latitude reefs of southeast Florida are currently non-accreting, relict systems with low coral cover. This region also did not support the extensive Late Pleistocene reef development observed in many other locations around the world; however, there is evidence of significant reef building in southeast Florida during the Holocene. Using 146 radiometric ages from reefs extending similar to 120 km along Florida's southeast coast, we test the hypothesis that the latitudinal extent of Holocene reef development in this region was modulated by climatic variability. We demonstrate that although sea-level changes impacted rates of reef accretion and allowed reefs to backstep inshore as new habitats were flooded, sea level was not the ultimate cause of reef demise. Instead, we conclude that climate was the primary driver of the expansion and contraction of Florida's reefs during the Holocene. Reefs grew to 26.7 degrees N in southeast Florida during the relatively warm, stable climate at the beginning of the Holocene Thermal Maximum (HTM) similar to 10,000 years ago, but subsequent cooling and increased frequency of winter cold fronts were associated with the equatorward contraction of reef building. By similar to 7800 years ago, actively accreting reefs only extended to 26.1 degrees N. Reefs further contracted to 25.8 degrees N after 5800 years ago, and by 3000 years ago reef development had terminated throughout southern Florida (24.5-26.7 degrees N). Modern warming is unlikely to simply reverse this trend, however, because the climate of the Anthropocene will be fundamentally different from the HTM. By increasing the frequency and intensity of both warm and cold extreme-weather events, contemporary climate change will instead amplify conditions inimical to reef development in marginal reef environments such as southern Florida, making them more likely to continue to deteriorate than to resume accretion in the future.

Automated summary

This study examines the development history of coral reefs in southeast Florida and finds that climate was the primary driver of expansion and contraction of reefs in the region during the Holocene. With climate change, the range of reef building in the Holocene progressively narrowed, ultimately ceasing reef development in southern Florida around 3000 years ago.