Comparison of LPWAN Technologies: Cost Structure and Scalability

Small-scale commercial rollouts of Cellular-IoT (C-IoT) networks have started globally since last year. However, among the plethora of low power wide area network (LPWAN) technologies, the cost-effectiveness of C-IoT is not certain for IoT service providers, small and greenfield operators. Today, there is no known public framework for the feasibility analysis of IoT communication technologies. Hence, this paper first presents a generic framework to assess the cost structure of cellular and non-cellular LPWAN technologies. Then, we applied the framework in eight deployment scenarios to analyze the prospect of LPWAN technologies like Sigfox, LoRaWAN, NB-IoT, LTE-M, and EC-GSM. We consider the inter-technology interference impact on LoRaWAN and Sigfox scalability. Our results validate that a large rollout with a single technology is not cost-efficient. Also, our analysis suggests the rollout possibility of an IoT communication Technology may not be linear to cost-efficiency.

Automated summary

This study discusses the global commercial rollouts of small-scale Cellular-IoT networks and proposes a generic framework for assessing the cost structure of cellular and non-cellular LPWAN technologies. The results indicate that large rollouts with a single technology are not cost-efficient, and the possibility of IoT communication technology rollout may not be linearly related to cost efficiency.