Including leaf trait information helps empirical estimation of jmax from vcmax in cool-temperate deciduous forests

Understanding the uncertainty in the parameterization of the two photosynthetic capacity parameters, leaf maximum carboxylation rate (Vcmax), and maximum electron transport rate (Jmax), is crucial for modeling and predicting carbon fluxes in terrestrial ecosystems. In gas exchange models, to date, Jmax is typically estimated from Vcmax based on a linear regression. However, recent studies have revealed that this relationship varies, dependent upon species, leaf groups, and time, so it is doubtful that the regression applies universally. Furthermore, far less is known regarding how other leaf traits affect the regression. In this study we analyzed the two key photosynthetic parameters and popularly measurable leaf traits, leaf chlorophyll concentration and leaf mass per area (LMA), of cool-temperate forest stands in Japan, aiming to construct a simple regression applicable to temperate deciduous forests, at least. The analysis was based on a long-term field dataset covering years of data for both sunlit and shaded leaves at different altitudes. Results showed that the best-fitted slope of the regression differed markedly from those previously reported, which were typically acquired from sunlit leaves. LMA had a significant effect on the regression, producing the lowest root mean square errors and the highest ratio of performance to deviation values (RPD = 2.017). Although more data are needed to validate in other ecosystems, our approach at least provides a promising way to substantially improve photosynthesis model predictions, by introducing leaf traits into the popular empirical regression of Jmax against Vcmax, and ultimately to better understand the functioning of the photosynthetic machinery.

Automated summary

Understanding the uncertainty in parameterization of Vcmax and Jmax is crucial for predicting carbon fluxes. Recent studies have shown that the relationship between Vcmax and Jmax varies depending on species and leaf traits. Our analysis in cool-temperate forest stands in Japan revealed that leaf traits, particularly LMA, significantly influence the regression, leading to improved model predictions.