期刊
BMC MEDICAL RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
卷 21, 期 1, 页码 -出版社
BMC
DOI: 10.1186/s12874-021-01293-y
关键词
Accuracy; Adaptive design; Diagnostic research; Patient-relevant outcome; RCT; Sample size; Test-treatment
资金
- German Research Foundation [ZA 687/1-1]
Diagnostic accuracy studies focus on the accuracy of new experimental tests, while randomized test-treatment studies evaluate the impact of diagnostic information on treatment strategies and patient outcomes. However, the various designs and inconsistent nomenclature in the literature pose challenges, highlighting the need for further research on these complex studies.
BackgroundDiagnostic accuracy studies aim to examine the diagnostic accuracy of a new experimental test, but do not address the actual merit of the resulting diagnostic information to a patient in clinical practice. In order to assess the impact of diagnostic information on subsequent treatment strategies regarding patient-relevant outcomes, randomized test-treatment studies were introduced. Various designs for randomized test-treatment studies, including an evaluation of biomarkers as part of randomized biomarker-guided treatment studies, are suggested in the literature, but the nomenclature is not consistent.MethodsThe aim was to provide a clear description of the different study designs within a pre-specified framework, considering their underlying assumptions, advantages as well as limitations and derivation of effect sizes required for sample size calculations. Furthermore, an outlook on adaptive designs within randomized test-treatment studies is given.ResultsThe need to integrate adaptive design procedures in randomized test-treatment studies is apparent. The derivation of effect sizes induces that sample size calculation will always be based on rather vague assumptions resulting in over- or underpowered study results. Therefore, it might be advantageous to conduct a sample size re-estimation based on a nuisance parameter during the ongoing trial.ConclusionsDue to their increased complexity, compared to common treatment trials, the implementation of randomized test-treatment studies poses practical challenges including a huge uncertainty regarding study parameters like the expected outcome in specific subgroups or disease prevalence which might affect the sample size calculation. Since research on adaptive designs within randomized test-treatment studies is limited so far, further research is recommended.
作者
我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。
推荐
暂无数据