EEG changes reflecting pain: is alpha suppression better than gamma enhancement?

Objective. - Suppression of alpha and enhancement of gamma electroencephalographic (EEG) power have both been suggested as objective indicators of cortical pain processing. While gamma activity has been emphasized as the best potential marker, its spectral overlap with pain-related muscular responses is a potential drawback. Since muscle contractions are almost universal concomitants of physical pain, here we investigated alpha and gamma scalp-recorded activities during either tonic pain or voluntary facial grimaces mimicking those triggered by pain. Methods. - High-density EEG (128 electrodes) was recorded while 14 healthy participants either underwent a cold pressor test (painful hand immersion in 10 degrees C water) or produced stereotyped facial/nuchal contractions (grimaces) mimicking those evoked by pain. The scalp distribution of spectral EEG changes was quantified via vector-transformation of maps and compared between the pain and grimacing conditions by calculating the cosine of the angle between the two corresponding topographies. Results. - Painful stimuli significantly enhanced gamma power bilaterally in fronto-temporal regions and decreased alpha power in the contralateral central scalp. Sustained cervico-facial contractions (grimaces) gave also rise to significant gamma power increase in fronto-temporal regions but did not decrease central scalp alpha. While changes in alpha topography significantly differed between the pain and grimace situations, the scalp topography of gamma power was statistically indistinguishable from that occurring during grimaces. Conclusion. - Gamma power induced by painful stimuli or voluntary facial-cervical muscle contractions had overlapping topography. Pain-related alpha decrease in contralateral central scalp was less disturbed by muscle activity and may therefore prove more discriminant as an ancillary pain biomarker. (C) 2021 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.

Automated summary

This study aimed to compare EEG activity during pain and facial grimaces. Results showed that painful stimuli significantly increased gamma power and decreased alpha power, while sustained facial-neck muscle contractions also increased gamma power but did not decrease alpha power. Pain-related alpha decrease in contralateral central scalp was less disturbed by muscle activity, which may prove to be a more discriminant ancillary pain biomarker.