A comparison of metric scoring and health status classification methods to evaluate benthic macroinvertebrate-based index of biotic integrity performance in Poyang Lake wetland

Methods for metric scoring and health status classification in development of index of biotic integrity (IBI) vary considerably across published studies. The difference between ecosystem health assessment results from these alternative methods for scoring and classification has rarely been studied systematically. Poyang Lake in China has experienced severe degradation over recent decades. Here, we aimed to develop a benthic macroinvertebrate-based index of biotic integrity (B-IBI) to assess the wetland health of Poyang Lake, and to evaluate the difference in assessment results using different methods of scoring and classification. Data on benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages, water quality and human-induced disturbances were collected at 30 sampling sites. Forty-nine attributes of macroinvertebrate assemblages were tested, and only the attributes that were significantly correlated with disturbance gradients or showed strong discriminatory power between reference and impaired sites were selected as the B-IBI metrics. Two scoring, two thresholding and three classification methods were applied for metric scoring and health status classification. Five assemblage attributes, i.e. the number of taxa, Shannon-Wiener diversity index, % Diptera, ASPT index and the number of predator taxa, were selected as the B-IBI metrics. Health status assessments varied considerably among the various metric scoring and classification methods, suggesting the importance of standardizing the methods for scoring and classification to be able to compare assessment results across different areas and time periods. The wetland health of Poyang Lake was rated as fair, which indicates that the wetland has experienced anthropogenic pressure and substantial changes in macroinvertebrate assemblage structure. Further, sample sites adjacent to tributary river mouths were in poor or very poor condition, suggesting that pollutant input by rivers has strong negative impacts on wetland health. Effective management of the entire lake basin and its watershed is therefore important for the wetland conservation. (C) 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Automated summary

The study highlights the considerable variation in health status assessments resulting from different scoring and classification methods in developing the Index of Biotic Integrity (IBI). The wetland health of Poyang Lake was rated as fair, indicating anthropogenic pressure and substantial changes in macroinvertebrate assemblage structure have impacted the wetland.