Young Adult Populations Face Yet Another Barrier to Care With Insurers: Limited Access to Proton Therapy

Purpose: Young patients, including pediatric, adolescent, and young adult (YA) patients, are most likely to benefit from the reduced integral dose of proton beam radiation therapy (PBT) resulting in fewer late toxicities and secondary malignancies. This study sought to examine insurance approval and appeal outcomes for PBT among YA patients compared with pediatric patients at a large-volume proton therapy center. Methods and Materials: We performed a cross-sectional cohort study of 284 consecutive patients aged 0 to 39 years for whom PBT was recommended in 2018 through 2019. Pediatric patients were defined as aged 0 to 18 years and YA patients 19 to 39 years. Rates of approval, denials, and decision timelines were calculated. Tumor type and location were also evaluated as factors that may influence insurance decisions. Results: A total of 207 patients (73%) were approved for PBT at initial request. YA patients (n = 68/143, 48%) were significantly less likely to receive initial approval compared with pediatric patients (n = 139/141; 99%) (P<.001). Even after 47% (n = 35 of 75) of the PBT denials for YA patients were overturned, YAs had a significantly lower final PBT approval (72% vs pediatric 99%; P<.001). The median wait time was also significantly longer for YA patients (median, 8 days; inter-quartile range [IQR] 3-17 vs median, 2 days; IQR, 0-6; P<.001). In those patients requiring an appeal, the median wait time was 16 days (IQR, 9-25). Conclusion: Given the decades of survivorship of YA patients, PBT is an important tool to reduce late toxicities and secondary malignancies. Compared with pediatric patients, YA patients are significantly less likely to receive insurance approval for PBT. Insurance denials and subsequent appeal requests result in significant delays for YA patients. Insurers need to re-examine their policies to include expedited decisions and appeals and removal of arbitrary age cutoffs so that YA patients can gain easier access to PBT. Furthermore, consensus guidelines encouraging greater PBT access for YA may be warranted from both medical societies and/or AYA experts. (C) 2021 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Automated summary

This study found that young adult (YA) patients are significantly less likely to receive insurance approval for proton beam radiation therapy (PBT) compared to pediatric patients. Insurance denials and subsequent appeal requests cause significant delays for YA patients. Insurers need to re-examine their policies to facilitate easier access to PBT for YA patients.