Spatiotemporal Heterogeneity across Metastases and Organ-Specific Response Informs Drug Efficacy and Patient Survival in Colorectal Cancer

The sum of target lesions is routinely used to evaluate patient objective responses to treatment in the RECIST criteria, but it fails to address response heterogeneity across metastases. This study argues that spatiotemporal heterogeneity across metastases and organspecific response is informative for drug efficacy and patient survival. We analyzed the longitudinal data of 11,404 metastatic lesions in 2,802 colorectal cancer patients from five phase III clinical trials. Initially, a metric Gower distance was applied to quantify response heterogeneity across metastases. Next, the spatiotemporal response heterogeneity across anatomic sites, therapies, and KRAS mutation status was assessed and examined for its association with drug efficacy and long-term patient survival. The response of metastatic lesions broadly differed across anatomic sites and therapies. About 60% of patients had at least one lesion respond contrarily from total tumor size. High interlesion heterogeneity was associated with shorter progression-free survival and overall survival. Targeted therapies (bevacizumab or panitumumab) combined with standard chemotherapy reduced interlesion heterogeneity and elicited more favorable effects from liver lesions (P < 0.001) than chemotherapy alone. Moreover, the favorable responses in liver metastases (> 30% shrinkage) were associated with extended patient overall survival (P < 0.001), in contrast to lesions in the lungs and lymph nodes. Altogether, the spatiotemporal response heterogeneity across metastases informed drug efficacy and patient survival, which could improve the current methods for treatment evaluation and patient prognosis. Significance: These findings support the modification of RECIST criteria to include individual lesion response to improve assessments of drug efficacy.

Automated summary

The response of metastatic lesions varies across different anatomic sites and therapies. High interlesion heterogeneity is associated with shorter survival, highlighting the potential benefits of targeted therapies in reducing heterogeneity and improving efficacy. Favorable responses in liver metastases are linked to extended overall survival, while lesions in other organs show less favorable outcomes.