Efficacy of biorational insecticides against Bemisia tabaci (Genn.) and their selectivity for its parasitoid Encarsia formosa Gahan on Bt cotton

The toxicity of seven biorational insecticides [five insect growth regulators (Buprofezin, Fenoxycarb, Pyriproxyfen, Methoxyfenozide, and Tebufenozide) and two oil-extracts of neem and bitter gourd seeds] against Bemisia tabaci and their selectivity for its parasitoid, Encarsia formosa were evaluated in laboratory and field conditions for 2 years (2018-2019) in Pakistan. Toxicity results demonstrate that Pyriproxyfen, Buprofezin, and Fenoxycarb proved to be effective (80-91% mortality and 66.3-84.2% population-reduction) against B. tabaci followed by Methoxyfenozide, Tebufenozide (50-75% mortality and 47.8-52.4% population-reduction), and then oil-extracts of neem and bitter gourd (25-50% mortality and 36.5-39.8% population-reduction) in the laboratory [72 h post-application exposure interval (PAEI)] and field trails (168 h PAEI), respectively. All tested biorationals, except Methoxyfenozide [(slightly-harmful/Class-II), i.e., causing mortality of parasitoids between a range of 25-50%] and Tebufenozide [(moderately-harmful/Class-III), i.e., causing mortality of parasitoids between the ranges of 51-75%], proved harmless/Class-I biorationals at PAEI of 7-days in the field (parasitism-reduction<25%) and 3-days in the lab (effect<30%). In laboratory bioassays, exposure of parasitized-pseudopupae and adult-parasitoids to neem and bitter gourd oils demonstrated that these compounds proved harmless/Class-I biorationals (<30% mortality). Alternatively, Pyriproxyfen, Buprofezin, Fenoxycarb, Methoxyfenozide, and Tebufenozide were slightly-harmful biorationals (30-79% mortality) against the respective stages of E. formosa. We conclude that most of the tested biorationals proved harmless or slightly harmful to E. formosa, except tebufenozide after PAEI of 7-days (168 h) in the field and, therefore, may be used strategically in Integrated Pest Management (IPM) of B. tabaci.

Automated summary

In a study conducted in Pakistan, it was found that Pyriproxyfen, Buprofezin, and Fenoxycarb were effective against Bemisia tabaci while being harmless to its parasitoid, Encarsia formosa. Neem and bitter gourd seed oil-extracts had some impact on B. tabaci but were slightly harmful to the parasitoid. Most tested biorational insecticides were either harmless or slightly harmful to E. formosa.