Bioactivity studies of porphyrinoids against microsporidia isolated from honeybees

Microsporidian infections are dangerous to honeybees due to the absence of an efficient treatment for nosemosis. In the present work, the abilities of several porphyrins to directly inactivate microsporidia derived from Nosema-infected honeybees were studied in vitro. Amide derivatives of protoporphyrin IX (PPIX) conjugated with one and two amino acid moieties were synthesized, and their activities were compared with those of two cationic porphyrins, TMePyP and TTMePP. The most active porphyrins, PP[Lys-Asp](2), PP[Lys-TFA](2), PP[Asp(ONa)(2)](2) and PP[Lys-Lys](2) at concentrations as low as 10-50 mu M exerted significant effects on microsporidia, reducing the number of spores by 67-80% compared to the control. Live-cell imaging of the spores treated with porphyrins showed that only 1.6% and 3.0% of spores remained alive after 24 h-incubation with 50 mu M PP[Asp(ONa)(2)](2) and PP[Lys-Asp](2), respectively. The length of the amino acid side chains and their identity in the PPIX molecules affected the bioactivity of the porphyrin. Importantly, the irradiation of the porphyrins did not enhance their potency in destroying Nosema spores. We showed that the porphyrins accumulated inside the living spores but not inside dead spores, thus the destruction of the microsporidia by non-metallated porphyrins is not dependent on photosensitization, but is associated with their active transport into the spore cell. When administered to honeybees in vivo, PPIX[Lys-TFA](2) and PPIX[Lys-Lys](2) reduced spore loads by 69-76% in infected individuals. They both had no toxic effect on honeybees, in contrast to zinc-coordinated porphyrin.