Impact of various iodine concentrations of iohexol and iodixanol contrast media on image reconstruction techniques in a vascular-specific contrast media phantom: quantitative and qualitative image quality assessment

Purpose The aim of our study is to investigate the impact of iodine quantification on image reconstruction when employing a vascular-specific contrast media phantom with varying iodine concentrations. Materials and methods A 30-cm phantom simulating arterial and venous blood vessel diameters was manufactured. Small (9 mm) and medium (12 mm) cylinders contained iodine concentrations from 10 to 100% while large (21 mm) cylinders were in quartiles from 25 to 100% diluted in blood equivalent medium. Each phantom was filled with either iohexol 350 mgI/mL (Group A) or iodixanol 320 mgI/mL (Group B) and then scanned separately. For each group, tube potential (80-140 kVp) and current (50-400 mAs) were changed and all image series were reconstructed with filtered back projection (FBP), hybrid-based iterative reconstruction (HBIR) and model-based iterative reconstruction (MBIR). Mean opacification was measured in all groups. All data were compared employing an independentttest and Pearson's correlation. Visual grading characteristic (VGC) and Cohens' kappa analyses were performed. Results At 80 kVp, mean opacification using HBIR was significantly higher in Group B (2165 +/- 1108 HU) than in Group A (2040 +/- 1036 HU) (p < 0.009). At 140 kVp, MBIR and HBIR were greater in Group A (1704 +/- 1033 HU and 1685 +/- 1023 HU) versus Group B (1567 +/- 1036 HU and 1567 +/- 1034 HU) (p < 0.022). CNR using FBP, HBIR and MBIR was higher in Group B (46 +/- 42 HU, 70 +/- 163 HU and 83 +/- 74 HU, respectively) than in Group A (43 +/- 39 HU, 174 +/- 130 HU and 80 +/- 65 HU, respectively) (p < 0.0001-0.035). Qualitative image analysis demonstrated no difference in Cohen's kappa analysis. VGC was higher in Group A at all image reconstruction groups. Conclusion Iohexol outperforms iodixanol in observer performance when assessing image reconstruction techniques and iodine concentrations in a vascular-specific contrast media phantom.

Automated summary

The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of iodine quantification on image reconstruction using a vascular-specific contrast media phantom. The results showed that there were slight differences in the performance of different iodine media for image reconstruction under different tube voltage and current, with higher visual grading characteristic in one group than the other. In qualitative image analysis, no difference was found in Cohen's kappa analysis.