Measuring and Modeling Gravel Transport at Caspar Creek, CA, to Detect Changes in Sediment Supply, Storage, and Transport Efficiency

We developed a technique for reconstructing annual gravel yields and generated a 55-year record of gravel transport for the North Fork catchment of the Caspar Creek Experimental Watersheds in Northern California. The technique relies on field data collection including annual surveys of weir pond volumes and suspended sediment measurements, as well as an accounting for settling of suspended sediment and organic matter in the pond. We compared these annual yields to gravel yields predicted by the Wilcock two-fraction bed load transport model, which we calibrated from measured values at Caspar Creek. We considered three velocity-discharge relationships and found that values of hydraulic variables measured during storms produced the best fit between reconstructed and predicted annual gravel yields when years with large disturbances were excluded. We also compared predicted gravel transport rates to bed load transport rates measured from 1988 to 1995 with bed load pit samplers. We found that the calibrated model predictions agreed well with the field-measured bed load transport rates. To investigate the role of supply and storage on gravel transport, we compared the reconstructed gravel yields to predicted gravel yields and found that increased occurrence of landslides and headcut erosion in the 1990s and early 2000s did not lead to an increase in gravel yields. Instead, input of large downed wood in the 1990s created storage space and decreased bed load delivery to the weir pond. Plain Language Summary Bed load sediment yields are important for understanding catchment responses to natural and human caused disturbances, but are difficult to measure. We demonstrate a method that uses pond sediment accumulations to quantify annual bed load yields at Caspar Creek, CA. We also use these data and data collected during more focused storm-based sampling to show that a common bed load model provides relatively accurate estimates of gravel transport at Caspar Creek. Comparing annual gravel yields to predicted gravel yields reveals that gravel transport decreased in the 1990s and 2000s after a large number of trees blew down and increased the wood content in the channel. The approach presented here can be applied to other sites where similar data are available, such as other ponds or small reservoirs.