Dilution of Precision in Three Dimensional Angle-of-Arrival Positioning Systems

Dilution of precision (DOP) for time-of-arrival (TOA) or time-difference-of-arrival (TDOA) positioning systems has been thoroughly investigated. This is not the case for angle-of-arrival (AOA) positioning systems, especially three dimensional AOA systems. However, the recent increase in deployment of antenna arrays and multipath mitigation techniques make AOA systems more attractive. In this paper, the DOPs for position systems using range measurements are reviewed and an expression for 3D AOA DOP is derived. The average values of DOPs for different deployments of base station geometries are examined. It is found that for a 3D AOA system, unlike TOA or TDOA systems, vertical DOP (VDOP) is generally smaller than horizontal DOP (HDOP), and the best VDOP can be achieved when the base stations are at the same height as the user. Moving the base stations away from the plane of the user may decrease the HDOP and Geometric DOP (GDOP) slightly, but it also increases the VDOP. For applications that the height of the user changes frequently, the base stations should be deployed with height close to half the height of the area of interest.