Implications of spatially extensive historical data from surveys for restoring dry forests of Oregon's eastern Cascades

Dry western forests (e.g., ponderosa pine and mixed conifer) were thought to have been historically old and park-like, maintained by low-severity fires, and to have become denser and more prone to high-severity fire. In the Pacific Northwest, early aerial photos (primarily in Washington), showed that dry forests instead had variable-severity fires and forest structure, but more detail is needed. Here I used pre-1900 General Land Office Surveys, with new methods that allow accurate reconstruction of detailed forest structure, to test eight hypotheses about historical structure and fire across about 400,000 ha of dry forests in Oregon's eastern Cascades. The reconstructions show that only about 13.5% of these forests had low tree density. Forests instead were generally dense (mean = 249 trees/ha), but density varied by a factor of 2-4 across about 25,000-ha areas. Shade-tolerant firs historically were 17% of trees, dominated about 12% of forest area, and were common in forest understories. Understory trees and shrubs dominated on 83.5%, and were dense across 44.8% of forest area. Small trees (10-40 cm dbh) were >50% of trees across 72.3% of forest area. Low-severity fire dominated on only 23.5%, mixed-severity fire on 50.2%, and high-severity fire on 26.2% of forest area. Historical fire included modest-rotation (29-78 years) low-severity and long-rotation (435 years) high-severity fire. Given historical variability in fire and forest structure, an ecological approach to restoration would restore fuels and manage for variable-severity fires, rather than reduce fuels to lower fire risk. Modest reduction in white fir/grand fir and an increase in large snags, down wood, and large trees would enhance recovery from past extensive logging and increase resiliency to future global change. These forests can be maintained by wildland fire use, coupled, near infrastructure, with prescribed fires that mimic historical low-severity fires.