Identifying Six Types of Soil Shrinkage Curves from a Large Set of Experimental Data

A typical soil shrinkage curve is S-shaped and composed of four phases termed structural, proportional, residual, and zero shrinkage. However, many studies have not found all four soil shrinkage phases despite investigating the full spectrum of soil moisture content. The objectives of this paper were to determine different soil shrinkage types based on the presence of shrinkage phases and to define relationships between the parameters of different shrinkage types and soil properties. A total of 270 sets of shrinkage data were collected from published (N = 245) and our unpublished work (N = 25), covering a wide range of soil types, sample sizes, and measurement methods. According to the presence of different shrinkage phases, six types of soil shrinkage curves were classified using the shrinkage model proposed by Peng and Horn (2005). Soil shrinkage types generally depended on soil structure, but not on the measurement method. The coefficient of linear extensibility (COLE) had a positive relation with saturated soil bulk density (r = 0.50, P < 0.001), clay content (r = 0.20, P < 0.05), and soil organic carbon (SOC) content (r = 0.46, P < 0.001). This paper is the first to propose six soil shrinkage types that will improve our understanding of the relationship between soil structure and soil water content.