Self-similar occurrence of massless Dirac particles in graphene under a magnetic field

Intricate interplay between the periodicity of the lattice structure and that of the cyclotron motion gives rise to a well-known self-similar fractal structure of the energy eigenvalue, known as the Hofstadter butterfly, for an electron moving in lattice under magnetic field. Connected with the n = 0 Landau level, the central band of the Hofstadter butterfly is especially interesting in the honeycomb lattice. While the entire Hofstadter butterfly can be in principle obtained by solving Harper's equations numerically, the weak-field limit, most relevant for experiment, is intractable owing to the fact that the size of the Hamiltonian matrix, which needs to be diagonalized, diverges. In this paper, we develop an effective Hamiltonian method that can be used to provide an accurate analytic description of the central Hofstadter band in the weak-field regime. One of the most important discoveries obtained in this work is that massless Dirac particles always exist inside the central Hofstadter band no matter how small the magnetic flux may become. In other words, with its bandwidth broadened by the lattice effect, the n = 0 Landau level contains massless Dirac particles within itself. In fact, by carefully analyzing the self-similar recursive pattern of the central Hofstadter band, we conclude that massless Dirac particles should occur under arbitrary magnetic field. As a corollary, the central Hofstadter band also contains a self-similar structure of recursive Landau levels associated with such massless Dirac particles. To assess the experimental feasibility of observing massless Dirac particles inside the central Hofstadter band, we compute the width of the central Hofstadter band as a function of magnetic field in the weak-field regime.