Coexistence of competing parasitoids: which is the fugitive and where does it hide?

Most insects harbour a community of parasitoids that coexist in spite of competition for resources. One potential mechanism for coexistence of competitors is a tradeoff between dispersiveness and local competitive ability. Here we present a study of competition between the specialized parasitoids Hyposoter horticola and Cotesia melitaearum sharing the Glanville fritillary butterfly, Melitaea cinxia. Within one host generation, the parasitoid larvae interact inside the host during each of the three C. melitaearum generations. We founds that in the summer when the host is small, the solitary H. horticola is the superior competitor, suppressing the gregarious C. melitaearum as eggs or small larvae. When multiparasitism occurs in the autumn the two parasitoid species engage in physical combat and C. melitaearum is favoured. Finally, a previous study showed that in the third C. melitaearum generation the univoltine H. horticola grows quickly during its final instar, excluding young C. melitaearum simply through limited time and resources. We found that contrary to expectations of the evolution of gregariousness, C. melitaearum, which lives in sibling groups, has biting mandibles in the first instar while the solitary H. horticola has suctorial mouthparts. Previous studies suggest that the two parasitoids co-exist because H. Horticola is dispersive and C. melitaearum is a strong local competitor. However, putting together the results of this experiment and out recent understanding of the adult wasp foraging behaviours and large scale population dynamics, we conclude that H. horticola is both a superior local competitor and more dispersive than C. melitaearum. Cotesia melitaearum has no impact on the population dynamics of H. horticola, persisting as a fugitive using a small fraction the larvae left unparasitized by H. horticola.