Reproducibility of diffusion tensor imaging in normal subjects: an evaluation of different gradient sampling schemes and registration algorithm

Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) is very useful for investigating white matter integrity in ageing and neurological disorders; thus, evaluating its reproducibility under different acquisition protocols and analysis methods may assist in the design of clinical studies. To measure the reproducibility of DTI in normal subjects, this study include (1) depicting the reproducibility of DTI measurements in commonly used regions-of-interest analysis by intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and coefficient of variation (CV), (2) evaluating and comparing inter and intrasession test-retest reproducibility, and (3) illustrating the effect of the number of diffusion-encoding directions (NDED) and registration algorithms on measurement reproducibility. DTI measurements exhibit high reproducibility, with overall (430/480) ICC a parts per thousand yenaEuro parts per thousand 0.70, (478/480) within-subject CV (CVws) a parts per thousand currency sign10.00 % and between-subject CV (CVbs) ranging from 1.32 to 13.63 %. Repeated measures ANOVAs and paired t tests were conducted to compare inter and intrasession reproducibility with different diffusion sampling schemes and registration algorithms. Our results also confirmed that increasing the NDED could improve the accuracy and reproducibility of DTI measurements. In addition, we compared reproducibility indices that were derived using different registration algorithms, and a tensor-based deformable registration yielded the most reproducible results. Finally, we found that increasing the NDED could reduce the difference between the reproducibility of measurement derived using different registration algorithms and between the reproducibility of intersession and intrasession. Our results suggest that the choice of DTI acquisition protocol and post-processing methods can influence the accurate estimation and reproducibility of DTI measurements and should be considered carefully for clinical applications.