Acoel development indicates the independent evolution of the bilaterian mouth and anus

Most bilaterian animals possess a through gut with a separate mouth and anus(1). It is commonly believed that during the transition from radial to bilateral symmetry, both openings evolved simultaneously by the lateral closure of a slit- like blastopore(1-4). Molecular phylogenies however, place the acoel flatworms, which have only one opening to their digestive system, as the sister group to all remaining Bilateria(5-7). To address how this single body opening is related to the mouth and anus of the protostomes and deuterostomes, we studied the expression of genes involved in bilaterian foregut and hindgut patterning during the development of the acoel Convolutriloba longifissura. Here we show that the genes brachyury and goosecoid are expressed in association with the acoel mouth, suggesting that this single opening is homologous to the mouth of other bilaterians(8). In addition, we find that the genes caudal, orthopedia and brachyury - which are expressed in various bilaterian hindguts(8-10) - are expressed in a small region at the posterior end of the animal, separated from the anterior oral brachyury- expressing region by a dorsal domain of ectodermal bmp2/4 expression. These results contradict the hypothesis that the bilaterian mouth and anus evolved simultaneously from a common blastoporal opening, and suggest that a through gut might have evolved independently in different animal lineages.