A case for a new paradigm in genetic toxicology testing

The field of genetic toxicology is in need of a transformational change in experimental approaches and data interpretation so that genotoxicity data can better inform risk assessment. The historical approach of the one-hit theory for DNA-reactive chemicals and the view of genotoxicity as an inherent property of a chemical are being challenged, based on a better understanding of the complexity of molecular mechanisms of mutation. A seemingly simple, but hitherto rarely practiced, approach that could help catapult the field forward is the application of the fundamental tenet of toxicology, a better understanding of the dose-response. There is a growing body of evidence to support the existence of thresholds/NOAELs for genotoxic effects. even from DNA-reactive chemicals. It is also suggested that a better understanding of the internal and/or effective dose to the critical target, for both in vitro and in vivo experiments, can significantly help to improve characterization of the shape of the dose-response curve and serve to support cross-species extrapolation. These experimental design and data interpretation approaches will render genetic toxicology data more useful to inform the mode-of-action-based risk assessment process, and provide the paradigm shift necessary to help bring the field into the 21st century. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.