A tale of two Cbls: Interplay of c-Cbl and Cbl-b in epidermal growth factor receptor downregulation

The precise role of Cbl in epidermal growth factor (EGF) receptor (EGFR) endocytosis and trafficking remains to be fully uncovered. Here, we showed that mutant EGFR1044, which was truncated after residue 1044, did not associate with c-Cbl and was not ubiquitinated initially in response to EGF but was internalized with kinetics similar to those of wild-type EGFR. This finding indicates that c-Cbl-mediated ubiquitination is not required for EGF-induced EGFR endocytosis. We also showed that the previously identified internalization-deficient mutant receptor EGFR1010LL/AA bound to c-Cbl and was fully ubiquitinated in response to EGF, which indicates that c-Cbl binding and ubiquitination are not sufficient for EGFR internalization. We next investigated EGFR trafficking following EGFR internalization. We found that c-Cbl disassociation from EGFR occurred well in advance of EGFR degradation and that this event was concurrent with the selective dephosphorylation of EGFR at Y1045. This finding suggests that once EGFR is ubiquitinated, continual Cbl association is not required for EGFR degradation. Because EGFR1044 is ubiquitinated and degraded similarly to wild-type EGFR, we examined the role of another prominent Cbl homologue, Cbl-b, and found that Cbl-b was associated with both EGFR and EGFR1044. Further study showed that Cbl-b bound to EGFR at two regions: one in the C-terminal direction from residue 1044 and one in the N-terminal direction from residue 958. Moreover, Cbl-b association with EGFR rose markedly following a decrease in c-Cbl association, corresponding to a second peak of EGFR ubiquitination occurring later in EGFR trafficking. Using RNA interference to knock down both c-Cbl and Cbl-b, we were able to abolish EGFR downregulation. This knockdown had no affect on the rate of EGF-induced EGFR internalization. We found that the two Cbls accounted for total receptor ubiquitination and that while c-Cbl and Cbl-b are each alone sufficient to effect EGFR degradation, both are involved in the physiological, EGF-mediated process of receptor downregulation. Furthermore, these data ultimately reveal a previously unacknowledged temporal interplay of two major Cbl homologues with the trafficking of EGFR.