The role of role: learning in longitudinal integrated and traditional block clerkships

Medical Education 2012: 46:698710 Context Traditional block clerkship (BC) structures may not optimally support medical student participation in the workplace, whereas longitudinal integrated clerkship (LIC) structures seem more conducive to students active engagement in patient care over time. Understanding the ways in which these two clerkship models influence students roles and responsibilities can inform clinical learning programme design. Methods This was a multicentre qualitative study. We conducted semi-structured interviews with LIC and BC medical students at three institutions early and late in the core clinical year to explore their experiences with patients and the roles they served. Using the framework of workplace affordances, qualitative coding focused on students roles and qualities of the learning environment that invited or inhibited student participation. We compared transcripts of early- and late-year interviews to assess students changing roles and conducted discrepant case analysis to ensure that coding fit the data. Results Fifty-four students participated in interviews. They described serving three major roles in clinical care that respectively involved: providing support to patients; sharing information about patients across health care settings, and functioning in a doctor-like role. Both LIC and BC students served in the providing support and transmitting information roles both early and late in the year. By contrast, LIC students commonly served in the doctor-like role in managing their patients care, particularly late in the year, whereas BC students rarely served in this role. Continuity in settings and in supervisors, and preceptors endorsement of students legitimate role afforded opportunities for students to participate actively in patient care. Conclusions Although both LIC and BC students reported serving in important roles in supporting their patients and sharing information about their care, only LIC students consistently described opportunities to grow into a doctor role with patients. The high level of integration of LIC students into care systems and their deeper relationships with preceptors and patients enhanced their motivation and feelings of competence to provide patient-centred care.