Ecological structure and function differs between habitats dominated by seagrasses and green seaweeds

Marine vegetated habitats, e.g. seagrass meadows, deliver essential functions and services to coastal ecosystems and human welfare. Impacts induced by humans, however, have facilitated the replacement of seagrasses by alternative vegetation, e.g. green rhizophytic seaweeds. The implications of habitat shifts for ecosystem attributes and processes and the services they deliver remain poorly known. In this study, we compared ecosystem structure and function between Cymodocea nodosa seagrass meadows and bottoms dominated by Caulerpa prolifera, a green, native, rhizophytic seaweed, through 5 ecological proxies: (i) primary production (via community metabolism), (ii) composition and abundance of epifauna (a proxy for provision of habitat for epifauna), composition and abundance of (iii) small-sized (juvenile) and (iv) large-sized (adult) fishes (proxies for provision of habitat for fishes), and (v) sediment retention (a proxy for sediment stabilization). Four of these proxies were greater in C nodosa seagrass meadows than in C. prolifera beds: gross primary productivity (similar to 1.4 times), the total abundance, species density and biomass of small-sized fishes (similar to 2.1, 13 and 1.3 times, respectively), the total abundance and species density of large-sized fishes (similar to 3.6 and 1.5 times, respectively), and sediment stabilization (similar to 1.4 times). In contrast, the total abundance and species density of epifauna was larger (similar to 3.1 and 1.7 times, respectively) in C prolifera than in C. nodosa seagrass beds. These results suggest that ecosystem structure and function may differ if seagrasses are replaced by green rhizophytic seaweeds. Importantly, ecosystem functions may not be appropriate surrogates for one another. As a result, assessments of ecosystem services associated with ecosystem functions cannot be based on exclusively one service that is expected to benefit other services. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.