Evaluation of estimated genetic merit for carcass weight in beef cattle: Live weights, feed intake, body measurements, skeletal and muscular scores, and carcass characteristics

Genetic merit for growth rate, expressed as expected progeny difference for carcass weight (EPDCWT), is available for dairy and beef sires used in Ireland. The once predominantly Friesian (FR) dairy herd has experienced significant introgression of Holstein (HO) genes over the past two decades, and cross-breeding of dairy cows, not required to produce herd replacements, with beef bulls is common. The objective of this study was to compare growth rate, feed intake, live animal measurements and slaughter traits of progeny of Holstein-Friesian daily cows and bulls of two contrasting maturity beef breeds namely Aberdeen Angus (AA) and Belgian Blue (BB), each selected for either high (H) or low (L) estimated genetic merit for carcass weight. Two dairy strains (FR and HO) were also included giving six genetic groups in total. A total of 170 male progeny from spring-calving cows were artificially reared indoors and subsequently managed together at pasture until the end of their second grazing season when they were assigned to one of two mean slaughter weights (i) 560 kg (Light) or (ii) 620 kg (Heavy). Daily feed intake was recorded during the first winter and during finishing. Body measurements were recorded four times during the animals' life, and linear scoring was carried out at 9 months of age and again at slaughter. Carcasses were graded for conformation and fatness (15 point scale). Slaughter and carcass weights per day of age for AAH, AAI, BBH, BBL, FR and HO were 782, 719, 795, 793, 804 and 783 (SE 12.9) g, and 415, 372, 438, 436, 413 and 401 (SE 5.8) g, respectively. Corresponding values for carcass weight, kill-out proportion, carcass conformation class (15 point scale) and carcass fat class (15 point scale) were 314, 283, 334, 333, 317 and 305 (SE 4.7) kg, 526, 518, 553, 550, 519 and 511 (SE 2.9) g/kg, 6.2, 5.4, 8.0, 7.9, 5.3 and 3.7 (SE 0.26), and 9.8, 9.3, 7.4, 7.2, 9.3 and 8.2 (SE 0.26). There were significant interactions between estimated genetic merit for carcass weight and beef breed with the differences between H and L mainly expressed for AA only. Feed intake differences between H and L animals were negligible and largely attributable to the differences in live weight. Following scaling for live weight, beef breeds of high estimated genetic merit for carcass weight had lower skeletal measurements, indicating greater compactness, with the effect more pronounced in AA. It is concluded that using beef sires of estimated high genetic merit for carcass weight on dairy cows increases growth rate and carcass weight of the progeny but the effect may not be similar for all breeds. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.