Contrast Sensitivity of Cats and Humans in Scotopic and Mesopic Conditions

Kang I, Reem RE, Kaczmarowski AL, Malpeli JG. Contrast sensitivity of cats and humans in scotopic and mesopic conditions. J Neurophysiol 102: 831-840, 2009. First published May 20, 2009; doi:10.1152/jn.90641.2008. Human contrast sensitivity in low scotopic conditions is regulated according to the deVries-Rose law. Previous cat behavioral data, as well as cat and mice electrophysiological data, have not confirmed this relationship. To resolve this discrepancy at the behavioral level, we compared sensitivity in dim light for cats and humans in parallel experiments using the same visual stimuli and similar behavioral paradigms. Both species had to detect Gabor functions (SD = 1.5 degrees, spatial frequencies from 0 to 4 cpd, temporal frequency 4 Hz) presented 8 to the right or left of a central fixation point over an 8 log-unit range of adaptation levels spanning scotopic vision and extending well into the mesopic range. Cats had 0.74 log unit greater absolute sensitivity than that of humans for spatial frequencies <= 1/8 cpd. Cats had better contrast sensitivity overall for spatial frequencies < 1/2 cpd, whereas humans were more sensitive for spatial frequencies above this. However, most of the cat's sensitivity advantage for low spatial frequencies could be accounted for by the greater light-concentrating abilities of its optics. Contrast sensitivity to 4 cpd was poor or absent in the scotopic range for both species. For both, scotopic increment thresholds were proportional to the square root of retinal illuminance, in accordance with the deVries-Rose law. Overall, cat and human visual systems appear to operate under very similar constraints for rod vision, including the regulation of contrast sensitivity across adaptation levels. A companion paper compares sensitivity of neurons in the lateral geniculate nucleus to these behavioral data.