Contrasting responses of seagrass transplants (Posidonia australis) to nitrogen, phosphorus and iron addition in an estuary and a coastal embayment

Addition of nutrients to sediments has been proposed as a means of enhancing transplantation success in seagrasses. The effects of nutrient and iron additions to natural sediments on the growth and morphology of Posidonia australis transplants were evaluated in underwater plots in two contrasting environments: a coastal embayment (Princess Royal Harbour) with sandy sediments and little riverine input, and an estuary (Oyster Harbour) with organic-rich sediments and subject to seasonal river flow from a large rural catchment. Sixty six planting units spaced 1 m apart were transplanted in situ in each location. Nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) were added in a randomized factorial design using slow release fertilizer granules at the start of the experiment and repeated every 4-5 months for 2 years. In a concurrent experiment, chelated iron Fe EDTA was added to modify the sediment sulphur cycle. In Oyster Harbour, the addition of N significantly increased leaf N concentrations but reduced total biomass and biomass of leaves. Addition of P significantly increased leaf P concentrations and number of living leaves per transplant, leaf area, leaf length, length of longest rhizome axis and total rhizome length. Combined N + P addition resulted in a significant increase in leaf P concentrations and leaf area per plant only. In Princess Royal Harbour, addition of N produced significant increases in leaf variables (total and leaf biomass, number of shoots and living leaves, leaf area, and leaf length) but there were no significant differences observed in below ground plant parts (rhizomes). Addition of P had no significant effects on any growth measurements. Addition of N + P combined increased number of living leaves and leaf area significantly. delta N-15 in mature leaf tissue were significantly more negative for N and N + P treatments at both locations. Our results indicated that N limitation was occurring in the coastal embayment, Princess Royal Harbour whereas in the more estuarine Oyster Harbour, P was limiting plant growth. Addition of FeEDTA produced equivocal results at both sites and we suggest these results are confounded by the addition of N and C in the EDTA. We caution the use of nutrient addition to transplants of slow growing seagrasses such as P australis without a thorough understanding of the nutrient status of the system, estuarine or coastal embayment, in which they are to be transplanted. (c) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.