Investigation of the Hydrate Plugging and Non-Plugging Properties of Oils

Three laboratories (Norwegian Institute of Science and Technology [NTNU], Institut Francais du Petrole [IFP], and the Colorado School of Mines [CSM]) determined hydrate plug formation characteristics in three oils, each in three conditions: (1) in their natural state, (2) with asphaltenes removed, and (3) with naturally occurring acids removed from the oil. The objective was to determine the major variables that affect hydrate plugging tendencies in oil-dominated systems, to enable the flow assurance engineer to qualitatively assess the tendency of an oil to plug with hydrates. In the past, it was indicated that chemical effects, for example, water-in-oil/hydrate-in-oil (emulsion/dispersion) stability, prevented hydrate plugs. For example, deasphalted oils provided low emulsion/dispersion stability and thus hydrate particles aggregated. In contrast pH 14-extracted oils were reported to remove stabilizing naphthenic acids, causing asphaltene precipitation on water/hydrate droplets, stabilizing the emulsion/dispersion to prevent aggregation and pluggage. This work suggests that in addition to chemistry, shear can enable plug-free operation in the hydrate region. High shear can prevent hydrate particle aggregation, while low shear encourages particle aggregation and plugging. As a result, flow assurance engineers may be able to forecast hydrate plug liability of an oil by a combination of chemistry and flow variables, such as: a) measurements of live oil emulsion stability, b) predictions of flow line shear, and c) knowledge of water cut. Plug formation qualitative trends are provided for the above three variables. Implications for flow assurance are given.