A Multidiagnostic Intercomparison of Tropical-Width Time Series Using Reanalyses and Satellite Observations

Poleward migration of the latitudinal edge of the tropics of 0.25 degrees-3.0 degrees decade(-1) has been reported in several recent studies based on satellite and radiosonde data and reanalysis output covering the past similar to 30 yr. The goal of this paper is to identify the extent to which this large range of trends can be explained by the use of different data sources, time periods, and edge definitions, as well as how the widening varies as a function of hemisphere and season. Toward this end, a suite of tropical edge latitude diagnostics based on tropopause height, winds, precipitation-evaporation, and outgoing longwave radiation (OLR) are analyzed using several reanalyses and satellite datasets. These diagnostics include both previously used definitions and new definitions designed for more robust detection. The wide range of widening trends is shown to be primarily due to the use of different datasets and edge definitions and only secondarily due to varying start-end dates. This study also shows that the large trends (>similar to 1 degrees decade(-1)) previously reported in tropopause and OLR diagnostics are due to the use of subjective definitions based on absolute thresholds. Statistically significant Hadley cell expansion based on the mean meridional streamfunction of 1.0 degrees-1.5 degrees decade(-1) is found in three of four reanalyses that cover the full time period (1979-2009), whereas other diagnostics yield trends of -0.5 degrees-0.8 degrees decade(-1) that are mostly insignificant. There are indications of hemispheric and seasonal differences in the trends, but the differences are not statistically significant.