Increased Reporting of Detectable Plasma HIV-1 RNA Levels at the Criticial Threshold of 50 Copies per Milliliter With the Taqman Assay in Comparison to the Amplicor Assay

Objective: To investigate the application of the new COBAS Ampliprep Taqman HIV-1 assay in comparison with the COBAS HIV-1 Ampliprep AMPLICOR MONITOR ultrasensitive assay version 1.5, with a particular focus On the most clinically relevant region near the lower limit of quatitification. Methods: Scatterplots and the Bland-Altman plot were used to inspect the degree of agreement between the :2 assays when tested on samples from the British Columbia Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS monitoring and evaluation system. Consistency of clinically applicable values at low HIV-1 RNA copy number was assessed from samples from individuals with previously undetectable Amplicor results. Results: Despite general agreement of these assays over a wide dynamic range, the Taqman assay resulted in a nearly 2-fold increase (from 3.6% to 6.9%) in the number of patients experiencing a plasma HIV-1 RNA level >50 copies per milliliter after being suppressed to levels <50 copies per milliliter consistently during the previous year (P < 0.01). In addition, rare discrepancies between the 2 assays were observed to be as high as 0.7 log(10) copies per milliliter. The kappa statistic was 0.19, indicating only slight agreement at the critical threshold of 50 HIV RNA copies per milliliter, with 43% Of undetectable samples in the Amplicor assay testing detectable in the Taqman assay (median 70 copies/mL.; interquartile range 60-83 copies/mL). Conclusions: The increased frequency of detectable plasma HIV-1 RNA levels at the threshold of 50 copies per milliliter with the new Taqman assay has important implications for highly active antiretroviral therapy monitoring. Until there is clinical evidence that patients with detectable HIV by the Taqman a.,say (but undetectable HIV with Amplicor) have differential outcome, it is unclear whether the Taqman assay is appropriate for routine management of HIV-1 therapy, and caution is required in the interpretation of low-level viremia by the Taqman assay until a clinical validation of a new cutoff is performed.