认证评论 - Solid Earth
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

rjww 2023-03-17

Posted on October 21, 2022;
Discussion started on November 10;
Two reviewers provided their revision comments on November 29 and December 7 respectively (major revision and minor revision);
Replied on January 16, 2023;
Uploaded revised manuscript on February 3;
Accepted on February 12;
Online on March 9.
The editor's handling speed is fast, and the reviewers' comments are professional. Due to the Chinese New Year, the revised manuscript was uploaded a bit late. If time is managed well, it can be submitted at least half a month earlier.

2022-08-31

Posted on February 4, 2022;
On February 21, the preprint was posted in the discussion area for public discussion;
On April 12 and May 4, two reviewers and the editor publicly provided revision suggestions in the discussion area;
On June 19, the author replied to the questions in the discussion area;
On June 22, the author uploaded the revised manuscript.
On June 28, the editor provided partial modification suggestions regarding language issues;
On July 8, the author uploaded the revised manuscript again.
On July 20, the editor stated that the manuscript met the acceptance criteria.
On August 12, the handling editor confirmed the acceptance.
Subsequently, it entered the proofreading process...
On August 31, the manuscript was published online.

In conclusion, the efficiency of communication with the editor was very high throughout the entire process of this journal. The overall duration of the process mainly depends on the reviewers.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started