yidada123 2022-11-16

It has been half a month, and it has been in the "Editor Invited" status all this time. Isn't it too slow? Does this journal not have any editors?

隐格本 2022-10-22

10.7 submitted
10.22 still submitted
What's going on?

隐格本 2022-10-13

I submitted it on the 10th of July, and on the 13th it is still showing "submissions being processed". This is my first submission, how many days approximately do you think it will take to receive feedback?

隐格本 2022-10-12

I submitted it on October 8th, and as of October 12th, it is still being processed. Since it is my first submission, approximately how many days will it take to receive feedback?

会飞的猪儿 2022-10-11

Posted on October 4th, received a response on October 6th saying the format was incorrect, and that the charts should be placed within the text with double spacing. After making the necessary changes, resubmitted on October 8th, but received another response on October 10th stating that the word count was too high and should be limited to 6500 words. It wasn't this complicated when I submitted an article over a decade ago.

DQS 2022-08-11

This is the first time I submitted to this publication. I received feedback for revisions two months ago, and now after completing the revisions, it has been 28 days without any results. I estimate that it will be just these two days left. Wish me good luck.

Joselfwei 2022-07-12

4 months, 2 rejections, 1 minor revision, rejected.
As a Q1 district journal, this speed is too slow.

FHHH 2022-06-21

6.21 Accepted, this post is concluded with confetti.

Q.11 2022-06-20

submitted to journal Apr 20, 2022
with editor May 10, 2022
under review May 10, 2022
significant Revise Jun 07, 2022
with editor Jun 26, 2022
Accept Jun 28, 2022
Both reviewers found the research content quite commendable and provided a total of 9 comments, which were relatively easy to address and modify.

Caorui 2022-06-19

It should be a formatting issue, check if it follows the 1. three-column format; 2. if both revised and clean versions have been submitted; 3. if all the charts have been placed at the end.

科研人在路上 2022-06-17

Everything is going smoothly, the external audit experts and editors are all very responsible, hoping that the journal will continue to improve.

Shy-1 2022-06-15

Hello! Do we have to format the revisions in a three-column form for repair? I haven't encountered this requirement before. Last time when I sent the revisions back, I directly sent them without any comments or emails. I don't know what happened.

Shy-1 2022-06-15

Hello, may I ask if the format for the feedback on repairs must be in a three-column format?

Shy-1 2022-06-15

"Revision sent back to author" means that the revised version of a document or text has been returned to the original author for their review or further edits.

老耗子 2022-06-14

Submitted on June 6th, and still not submitted by the 14th. Has this journal always been slow or has it recently become slower? It is my first time submitting to this journal, and I noticed that it is much slower than JHM and Chemosphere, which are both monthly journals.

Caorui 2022-06-13

1.21 submitted
2.20 resubmit after format modification
4.6 significant revisions
5.7 resubmitted
5.20 minor revisions
5.24 resubmitted
6.12 accepted

Translation:
1.21 - Submitted
2.20 - Resubmit after format modification
4.6 - Significant revisions
5.7 - Resubmitted
5.20 - Minor revisions
5.24 - Resubmitted
6.12 - Accepted

FHHH 2022-06-09

3.24 submitted
4.09 with editor
4.20 under review
5.28 revision
6.07 with editor

Translation:
3.24 - Submitted
4.09 - With editor
4.20 - Under review
5.28 - Revision
6.07 - With editor

LUTIE 2022-05-25

Submitted on May 18th, and it's still "Submitted to Journal" until now. How long does it usually take to be "with editor"? I want to withdraw my paper, it's too damn slow. I've never seen a journal in the environmental field this slow.

FHHH 2022-05-15

April 9th with the editor, submitted for review on April 20th, there is still no news.

科研乐 2022-05-07

Brother, with editor, it has been a few days under review. I have been waiting for half a month, and it is still submitted.

科研乐 2022-05-04

I have been waiting for 10 days, and it is still submitted. This journal is really slow.

neulailai 2022-05-04

May I ask if the number of charts in the submission file should not exceed 8, does it mean the total number of charts and tables should not exceed 8, or is it limited to 8 charts and 8 tables separately?

祖国万岁！ 2022-05-03

It is a three-column table. The first column is the reviewers' comments, the second column is our responses and modifications to the comments, and the third column is the specific location indicators of the changes you made in the manuscript, such as "see new lines 25, 28" like this. By the way, there are also some general questions in the editor's and reviewers' comments. It is suggested to respond to these questions as well. You can provide a textual response before the three-column table.

李 2022-05-03

It is a three-column table. The first column consists of comments proposed by the editor or reviewer. The second column is your response to these comments. The third column indicates the location of your modifications in the tracked changes table, such as line 56-line 58, highlighted in red.

科研乐 2022-04-29

Hello, how many reviewers does this journal usually have?

Caorui 2022-04-29

Hello, may I trouble you with a question? Are your review comments replied in the form of a three-column table? I haven't encountered this formatting before and would like to confirm.

Caorui 2022-04-29

Hello, is your review feedback replied in the form of a three-column table? The formatting feels strange.

李 2022-04-29

Finally received it, after going through ten months and 18 days. Although I received it, I will never submit to this journal again in the future! Too slow! Goodbye, waste management!

科研乐 2022-04-28

Brother, when did you submit? I have submitted for five days already, still "submitted".

春色浮寒瓮 2022-04-23

May I ask if there is a specific template for the paper format in the waste management journal? This is my first time submitting an article, and I am feeling overwhelmed by the author's guidelines.