认证评论 - TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES
lechen 2023-07-25
Accepted after two rounds of experience
Thank you again to my responsible editor!
我有一个roey 2023-07-19
The subject is not suitable and has been rejected.
The review process is very fast.
Submission date: 2023.07.13
Rejection date: 2023.07.14
lechen 2023-04-04
The reviewer and the editor are very responsible, and their comments are very pertinent. After the revisions, there has indeed been a significant improvement. I feel that I must pay attention to my own writing and expression. Best wishes to everyone for a good outcome!
NoNickName 2023-02-25
The total duration is approximately 11 months, and the rough timeline is as follows:
April 2022: Submission
July 2022: Major revisions
September 2022: Return
November 2022: Minor revisions
November 2022: Return
February 2023: Acceptance
Three reviewers provided very helpful feedback and were very diligent in reviewing both the first and second rounds. I am very grateful to them!
一 2022-09-06
Brother, how long is your first trial?
volin 2022-08-15
2022.2.23 Submitted, with editor for one month
2022.3.22 Under review
2022.5.9 Major revision
2022.6.24 Revised submitted
2022.8.9 Accepted
It took a total of over 5 months, and it would have been faster if it wasn't for the time spent with the editor. The speed is still good.
lechen 2022-07-10
Currently, less than two and a half months have been given for the first review, and major revisions are required.
I am grateful to the three reviewers, two of whom provided very pertinent comments and paid great attention to detail.
Finding responsible reviewers is truly not easy.
I hope that after the major revisions, I will not disappoint such responsible reviewers.
lz1113043608 2022-07-03
How long does it take for TRC to be indexed from acceptance to Web of Science? Thank you.
雾里看花 2022-06-08
2022.04.06: Article Submission
Currently, it is still under review. The article's theme revolves around autonomous driving in highway scenarios, utilizing data-driven methods and deep learning architectures to predict vehicle trajectories.
charity_123 2022-05-28
I would like to ask the seniors, how long does the second review process of this journal usually take?
Innovator 2022-04-30
The impact factor of TR Part C has recently increased significantly, while the processing speed remains fast. The entire process takes about six months. The opinions of the peer reviewers are comprehensive and fair, and they belong to the same field, able to clearly identify the strengths and weaknesses of the paper. The associate editor is also very professional.
Submit: 2021.07.01;
Major revision: 2021.10.28;
Resubmit: 2021.12.25;
Accept: 2022.01.30.
Eddy Lau 2021-12-03
Does "under review" belong to editor review or has it already been sent for external review?
Eddy Lau 2021-12-03
Does "under review" belong to the editor's review or has it been sent for external review already?
barbaraboy 2021-12-01
The impact factor is artificially high, all played within a small circle, and the quality of the articles is uneven.
3606 2021-07-21
The traffic discipline is indeed a waste of time, and the "Part" series are all games that revolve around small circles, which is ridiculously self-promoting.
xyz321 2021-07-19
Compared to the "big shots" in the industry who are stuck in their models and methodologies from two or three decades ago, just circling around and indulging themselves, taking the latest applications in the industry to imagine and fit them into existing model scenarios, creating a bunch of seemingly true but actually false propositions and algorithms, and then publishing in a so-called "top-tier journal", this kind of watering down using methods from other fields is slightly more clever, at least injecting some new technological ideas into this field (although it cannot be considered as first-class research). Honestly speaking, in the recent years, in the field of intelligent transportation, whether it is connected vehicles, electric vehicles, ride-hailing services, or autonomous driving, how much contribution has been made by traditional "transportation experts" leading the way? An applied discipline that does not focus on technological development and industrial revolution, but just revolves around a few outdated routines, I believe this field will eventually face the fate of being revolutionized.
xyz321 2021-07-19
It sounds like there are a few articles in the traditional transportation field that are not just spam...
David Raymond 2021-07-17
After half a year, another article was published.
The editor-in-chief has changed, but TR-C's efficiency has been maintained.
Submitted on January 21, 2021.
Major revisions in the first review on March 26, 2021.
Completed revisions and submitted on May 4, 2021.
Minor revisions in the second review on June 29, 2021.
Accepted on July 12, 2021.
letpubID 2021-06-24
The impact factor is artificially high, and there is an excessive pursuit of the so-called emerging technology. Too many papers on machine learning have been published, but they have made very little theoretical contribution to the field of transportation. The increase in impact factor is immediate, but the quality of the articles varies greatly.
The quality of papers in traditional fields is not as good as those in TRB and TRE, and the quality of papers in intelligent transportation is not as good as ITS.
The new editor-in-chief is a disciple of Daganzo, and it is hoped that there will be improvements in the positioning of the journal and the quality of peer review.
DoCatFish 2021-03-23
2021 changed the editor-in-chief.
Become a Peeref-certified reviewer
The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.
Get Started