认证评论 - Thin Solid Films
聪聪Belle 2023-07-25
May I ask how to withdraw a submission?
Gyul 2022-12-22
22/10/4 Submission
After format review, major revisions, and minor revisions, it was accepted on 22/12/21.
The journal is very rigorous, and the editorial department has very detailed requirements.
奥拉沃坎迪 2022-12-09
2022.12.08, finally received it. It took a whole 7 months...
奥拉沃坎迪 2022-11-24
Oh my, I submitted in May 2022, received revisions in September 2022, and it became "required reviews completed" on October 18th, 2022. It's still in that state as of November 24th, 2022. It's really slow, I hope it doesn't get rejected...
Leo 2022-04-13
It seems like my complaint was heard by the editor. After waiting for over five months, my manuscript was rejected today. In the end, I was reaching too high with TSF. I will never submit to TSF again. I wish them the best in their future endeavors...
Leo 2022-04-10
So speechless, submitted on 2021.11.03, required reviews completed on 2022.3.28, and still in the same status until now. There is also no reminder email, really living up to its reputation for being slow. The editing efficiency is too low.
呓 2022-04-07
May I ask where to find the template for submission requirements?
HLee 2022-03-12
I have also submitted to this journal. May I ask if there have been any updates on the status of my article?
Diamond 2022-02-15
It has been more than 10 days since submission, and the editor hasn't processed it yet. It's still in the submission stage to the journal. It's too slow, and I feel like it's dragging on. I want to withdraw my submission and submit elsewhere. Does anyone know how to withdraw a submission?
liudehua 2021-07-30
It has been slow for 2 months. I submitted two articles, and most of them took about 3-4 weeks to be under review. Then, after more than a month, I received feedback on the manuscript.
fangfei Lee 2021-03-15
I recently submitted an article, and it is still under review. It has been two months already. How long does it usually take? It feels so slow.
fangfei Lee 2021-03-15
I recently submitted a paper and it is still under review. How long does it usually take? It feels so slow.
Become a Peeref-certified reviewer
The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.
Get Started