Albert-wang 2022-11-25

2022.9.28 Submission
2022.10.18 Major revision; Four reviewers: 40 comments
2022.11.4 Submit revised manuscript
2022.11.17 Minor revision: one comment on grammar issues
2022.11.21 Submit
2022.11.25 Accepted
Overall, less than two months, the reviewers and editors were very efficient! Looking forward to even better results! JHM rejected, so it was redirected. Next article will aim for JHM.

咕噜碳 2022-11-24

May I ask where to submit Supplementary Information when submitting a manuscript? It is my first submission, and it is different from other journals.

hhraxx 2022-11-24

20220917-submit
20220923-under review
20221025-major revision
20221111-R1
20221124-accept
Round and round, not easy, thanks to Zongbi Bao for editing.

BoBogjxZhang 2022-11-16

Did you receive it in just over a month? I have been reviewing and making changes for over three months, and it is still under review...

@@!! 2022-11-15

Which field to invest in?

DALLER 2022-11-13

22.10.15 submit to spt - Submitted to SPT on October 22nd, 2015.
22.10.19 under review - Under review as of October 19th, 2022.
22.10.30 major revision - Major revision required by October 30th, 2022.
22.11. 7 r1 - First round of revisions completed on November 7th, 2022.
22.11.12 aceept - Accepted on November 12th, 2022.
The entire process took less than a month. Many thanks to Editor: Prof. Yi, as the handling speed was simply incredible!

qzzzzzzz97 2022-11-09

Sorry, I made a mistake in the comment.

冯丫丫 2022-11-08

Excuse me, how can I determine the number of major repairs and minor repairs needed?

不忘初心+1 2022-11-05

Posted on September 14th
Reviewed on September 15th
First review comments returned on October 7th
Revised on October 27th
Accepted on November 3rd
The speed is very fast, hoping for continuous improvement.

Allallallaccept 2022-11-04

Should the editor not handle this situation or reject the submission?

滚滚滚fg 2022-11-04

2022.8.11 submitted to journal
8.11 under review
9.02 major revision
10.06 revision submitted to journal
10.06 under review
10.14 major revision
10.23 revision submitted to journal
10.24 under review
11.03 accept
Successfully put a perfect ending to my master's career.
Thank you very much to editor Shouliang Yi for editing and handling the manuscript promptly and responsibly.

Yi-Chuan Huang 2022-11-03

Hello, I would like to ask, where can I check the status?

大猫丶 2022-11-01

2022.9.4 submitted to journal
9.5 with editor
9.6 under review
9.9 under review
9.26 major revision (two major, two minor)
10.17 revision submitted to journal
10.22 with editor
11.1 accept
Thank you to editor Jorge Bedia for the quick processing, the overall process took nearly two months, which felt great. I hope SPT continues to improve!

John Bull 2022-10-31

Usually it takes about a week, but sometimes it can take half a month. I saw in the previous posts downstairs that some required reviews were completed in about half a month. Let's wait a little longer, maybe there will be opinions from both sides, and the editor will consider it again or invite a third reviewer.

啦啦啦081 2022-10-31

May I ask how long does the status of "required reviews completed" last for the transition to the status of "major overhaul"?

John Bull 2022-10-31

What Lao Bian said is correct. The editor is still making a decision, it should be soon.

John Bull 2022-10-31

Submission experience:
2022.8.30 submit
2022.9.5 under review
2022.10.4 major revise
2022.10.24 review submitted to journal
2022.10.29 required reviewer completed
2022.10.30 accept
The reviewer's comments were incisive, greatly improving the quality of the article; the editor was very efficient and responsible. Thank you, editor Guohua Chen. I wish separation and purification technology continued to thrive!

啦啦啦081 2022-10-31

Excuse me, may I ask how long did it take for you to finally get the results, OP?

fyh21 2022-10-25

Submission Experience:
September 18, 2022 - Submitted
September 20, 2022 - Under review
September 30, 2022 - Major revision
October 14, 2022 - Review submitted to journal
October 23, 2022 - Required reviewer completed
October 24, 2022 - Accepted
Thank you, Shouliang Yi, for editing and handling the manuscript quickly and responsibly. Wishing SPT continued success!

中石油中中中 2022-10-23

Could it be a matter of direction? Some are sent for review faster, while others are slower.

fkalkas 2022-10-23

I submitted it on the 14th, and now it's the 23rd, it's still with the editor, not as fast as others have said.

如果你说 2022-10-22

After 6 months and 8 days, I finally received it. Thanks to the editor and the reviewing experts. This is my first doctoral article. It is truly difficult to start everything, and I hope everything goes smoothly from now on.

wjjokk 2022-10-22

I submitted mine on October 17th, and now it's still "with editor" on the 22nd. It hasn't been sent for review yet, and I feel like it's going to be rejected soon.

大猫丶 2022-10-22

The translation of "10.22 with editor" into English is "10.22 with editor."

中石油中中中 2022-10-22

2022.10.20 - Submitted
2022.10.21 - With Editor
2022.10.21 - Under Review
10.28 - Under Review
11.9 - Major Revision
11.28 - Under Review
12.12 - Accepted

大猫丶 2022-10-21

The deadline given by the senior editor for the major revision is October 18th.

大猫丶 2022-10-21

After reading many shared experiences, I gained a lot. I am sharing my first SCI submission experience in the hope of being accepted smoothly and helping everyone!
Submitted to journal on September 4, 2022.
With editor on September 5.
Under review on September 6.
Under review on September 9.
Major revision on September 26 (two major revisions and two minor revisions).
Revision submitted to journal on October 17.
Editor: Jorge Bedia.
The current status has not changed. Overall, the review process has been quite fast, but I am not sure about the second review. I hope everything goes smoothly!

如一zzz 2022-10-17

8.31 submitted to journal
9.1 with editor
9.1 under review
9.27 major revise
10.6 revision submitted to journal
10.7 under review
10.8 accept

Translation:
8.31 submitted to journal
9.1 with editor
9.1 under review
9.27 major revise
10.6 revision submitted to journal
10.7 under review
10.8 accept

Thank you, Editor Shuguang Deng. Wishing SPT to get better and better.

yyan 2022-10-10

8.26 submitted to journal
8.28 with editor
8.28 under review
9.16 major revision (21 days)
10.02 Revision submitted to journal
10.03 Under review
10.09 Required reviews completed
10.10 Accepted
Thank you, Editor Shuguang Deng, you were incredibly fast!!!

Albert-wang 2022-10-09

Yes, thank you. I hope for a good outcome. I will share it with everyone when the time comes!